Here are some pictures of that house. The stonework and the original front door and entry are so charming. I love houses with a vestibule, a place to take off your coat and boots. Having a double entry keeps a house warmer in our winters. This house still has the original 1920s tile in the vestibule.

And yet! The thing that makes it a dream house is the combination of old and new. It has the charm of an old 1920s house combined with a modern addition and a kitchen to die for. Cherry cabinets, a viking range, double oven, undermount sink...

And closets! Closets galore. Double closets in the master suite, which also has its own private deck, and a bathtub in a turret. A turret! This addition is so well done because it is a high-quality addition (brick), but also well designed architecturally. There are so many additions in this neighborhood that are basically just giant blocks added on to the back of a house. This one was an interesting architectural addition to the house, and nothing like a giant block.
And the closets!

So the house has closets, an open family room / dining room / kitchen area, 2.5 baths, but also an original portion with an office off the living room, the original fireplace, and period details. I just love this view from the living room into the vestibule towards the front door, for instance:

And then the open family area in the addition has nice details like tray ceilings:
So Wednesday I stayed home with the kids, and Milo was sick, and I spent 10 hours cleaning and decluttering our house. Then I cooked dinner, then after the kids went to bed I had several friends from the neighborhood over for wine and dessert. Two of them live on the same street as our dream house, so we talked about that.
The funniest thing is that I told them about how I have a nemesis who I didn't want to get the house. (I'll call her RT). And one of my friends immediately said, "is it RT?" This friend has never heard me say RT's name, I've never talked about RT with her, and yet she pulled that name out of thin air! I was flabbergasted. My friend isn't even a professor, how does she even know RT? She said, "I just thought of her for some reason because she's basically your opposite."
Yesterday morning I got up, rushed the kids to school, did some last-minute cleaning prep, then went and saw the house. Confirmed our decision to make an offer. Came home, showed our house to people. Then called Jake, we decided to meet up over lunch with our realtor to write up the offer. Then, Milo's school called. His teacher thought he was still sick. So I went and got him. Change of plans, Jake would come home to write the offer. Jake came home. Jake, Milo and I looked at the house again. Then we went back to our house and wrote the offer while Milo napped.
Then Jake and I hyperventilated a bit because it was sooooooo expensive. Like, 20K more than the top of our psychological barrier for how much we'd ever want to pay for a house. Also, financing is not straightforward, at least it wouldn't be until we sold our own house. I put all the pictures of our own house up onto a web page, and we prepared to advertise it once our offer was accepted. It was a full priced offer with no contingency, so they'd be crazy not to accept it.
I went to the gym.
Came home. Our realtor called. Another couple has also written an offer, and they knew that another offer (ours) was already submitted when they wrote it. Even though realtors aren't allowed to reveal the details of a competing offer, they are allowed to reveal that there does exist a competing offer. So the 2nd couple knew about our offer (even though they didn't know how much it was for), and were probably writing a better one. A couple of hours went by, the kids went to bed. Our realtor called. A THIRD couple has written an offer, with the knowledge of the first two offers!
Midnight -- the sellers picked the 3rd offer, so we lost the house. They must have gone above the asking price.
Although we are disappointed, a part of me is relieved too. It would have been a lot of money, maybe too much. It felt risky, and Jake and I are pretty conservative with our personal finances. There is something to be said for maintaining our nice small mortgage with only 18 years left on it. Also, the bright side is, we really do like so many things about our current house. Right now I'm sitting in our sunny kitchen (home again, of course, with sick kids, 5th day in a row) and appreciating the fact that our house gets so much sunlight.
So it has been a very dramatic week! I'll be glad when the kids are done being sick, when Jake and I start to feel better, when we can relax a little after all of this business and excitement. I'm looking forward to spring and replacing part of our fence and planting tomatoes (this time with chicken wire) and gardening and enjoying our park. It's all good.